Skip Navigation Links
synmmain 12
12pt
 

header Investor Relations | Risk Factors

You should carefully consider the risks described below, which have been updated from the Company’s previous disclosure of Risk Factors in its Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2006, principally for risks relating to our Biofining™ Technology. The risks and uncertainties described below encompass many of the risks that could affect our company. If any of the following risks actually occur, our business, financial condition or results of operations could be materially and adversely affected. In that case, the trading price of our common stock could decline and you may lose all or part of your investment in us.

 

 

Risks Relating to Our Technology

 

We might not successfully commercialize our technology, and commercial-scale plants based on the Syntroleum® Process or our Technology may never be successfully constructed or operated.

We do not have significant experience managing the financing, design, construction or operation of commercial-scale plants, and we may not be successful in doing so. No commercial-scale plant based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology has been constructed to date. A commercial-scale plant based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology may never be successfully built either by us or by our licensees. Success depends on our ability and/or the ability of our licensees to economically design, construct and operate commercial-scale plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology. Successful commercial construction and operation of a plant based on the Syntroleum® Process or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology depends on a variety of factors, many of which are outside our control.

 

Commercial-scale plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology might not produce results necessary for success, including results demonstrated on a laboratory, pilot plant and demonstration basis.

A variety of results necessary for successful operation of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology could fail to occur at a commercial plant, including reactions successfully tested on a laboratory, pilot plant or demonstration plant basis. Results that could cause commercial-scale plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes to be unsuccessful include:

·         lower reaction activity than demonstrated in the pilot plant and demonstration plan operations which would decrease the conversion of natural gas into synthesis gas and increase the amount of catalyst, and/or number of reactors required to produce the design synthesis gas rate;

·         lower reaction activity than that demonstrated in laboratory, pilot plant and demonstration plant operations, which would increase the amount of catalyst or number of reactors required to convert synthesis gas into liquid hydrocarbons and increase capital and operating costs;

·         shorter than anticipated catalyst life, which would require more frequent catalyst regeneration, catalyst purchases, or both, thereby increasing operating costs;

·         excessive production of gaseous light hydrocarbons from the FT reaction compared to design conditions, which would lower the anticipated amount of liquid hydrocarbons produced and would lower revenues and margins from plant operations;

·         lower reaction activity than that demonstrated in laboratory, pilot plant and demonstration plant operations, which would increase the amount of catalyst or number of reactors required to convert FT products into finished, marketable fuels;

·         inability of the gas turbines or heaters integrated into the Syntroleum® Process to burn the low-heating-value tail gas produced by the Process, which would result in the need to incorporate other methods to generate horsepower for the compression process that may increase capital and operating costs;

·         inability of third-party gasification and synthesis gas clean-up technology integrated into the Syntroleum® Process to produce quantities of quality synthesis gas adequate for economic operation of a CTL or BTL plant; and

·         higher than anticipated capital and operating costs to design, construct and operate a commercial scale plant.

Results that could cause commercial-scale plants based on our Bio-Synfining™ Technology to be unsuccessful include:

·         higher than anticipated catalyst or hydrogen consumption;

·         inadequate removal of feedstock impurities in pre-treatment;

·         lower process yields than that demonstrated in laboratory operations; and

·         higher than anticipated capital and operating costs to design, construct and operate a commercial scale plant.

 

In addition, these plants could experience mechanical difficulties related or unrelated to elements of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology.

 

Many of our competitors have significantly more resources than we do, and technologies developed by competitors could become more commercially successful than ours or render our technologies obsolete.

Development of FT and renewable fuels technologies is highly competitive, and other technologies could become more commercially successful than ours. The Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes is based on chemistry that has been used by several companies in synthetic fuel projects over the past 60 years. Our competitors include major integrated oil companies that have developed or are developing competing GTL, CTL, BTL or renewable fuels technologies, including BP, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, Sasol (including its participation in a joint venture with Chevron) and Shell. Each of these companies has significantly more financial and other resources than we do to spend for research and development of their technologies and for funding construction and operation of commercial-scale plants. In addition to using their own GTL, CTL, BTL or renewable fuels technologies in competition with us, these competitors could also offer to license their technology to others. Additionally, several smaller companies have developed and are continuing to develop competing GTL, CTL, BTL or renewable fuels technologies. The DOE has also sponsored a number of research programs relating to GTL, CTL, BTL and renewable fuels technologies that could potentially lower the cost of competitive processes.

As our competitors continue to develop GTL, CTL, BTL and renewable fuels technologies, one or more of our current technologies could become obsolete. Our ability to create and maintain technological advantages is critical to our future success. As new technologies develop, we may be placed at a competitive disadvantage, and competitive pressures may force us to implement new technologies at a substantial cost. We may not be able to successfully develop or expend the financial resources necessary to acquire new technology.

 

Our ability to protect our intellectual property rights involves complexities and uncertainties and commercialization of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology could give rise to claims that our technology infringes upon the rights of others.

 

Our success depends on our ability to protect our intellectual property rights, which involves complex legal, scientific and factual questions and uncertainties. We rely on a combination of patents, copyrights, trademarks, trade secrets and contractual restrictions to protect our proprietary rights. Additional patents may not be granted, and our existing patents might not provide us with commercial benefit or might be infringed upon, invalidated or circumvented by others. In addition, the availability of patents in foreign markets, and the nature of any protection against competition that may be afforded by those patents, is often difficult to predict and vary significantly from country to country. We, our licensors, or our licensees may choose not to seek, or may be unable to obtain, patent protection in a country that could potentially be an important market for our GTL, CTL, BTL or Bio-Synfining™ Technologies. The confidentiality agreements that are designed to protect our trade secrets could be breached, and we might not have adequate remedies for the breach. Additionally, our trade secrets and proprietary know-how might otherwise become known or be independently discovered by others.

Commercialization of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology may give rise to claims that our technologies infringe upon the patents or proprietary rights of others. We may not become aware of patents or rights that may have applicability in the GTL, BTL, CTL or renewable fuels industry until after we have made a substantial investment in the development and commercialization of those technologies. Third parties may claim that we have infringed upon past, present or future GTL, BTL, and CTL or renewable fuels technologies. Legal actions could be brought against us, our co-venturers or our licensees claiming damages and seeking an injunction that would prevent us, our co-venturers or our licensees from testing, marketing or commercializing the affected technologies. If an infringement action were successful, in addition to potential liability for damages, our co-venturers, our licensees or we could be required to obtain a license in order to continue to test, market or commercialize the affected technologies. Any required license might not be made available or, if available, might not be available on acceptable terms, and we could be prevented entirely from testing, marketing or commercializing the affected technology. We may have to expend substantial resources in litigation, either in enforcing our patents, defending against the infringement claims of others, or both. Many possible claimants, such as the major energy companies that have or may be developing proprietary GTL, CTL, BTL or renewable fuels technologies competitive with the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes and Bio-Synfining™ Technology, have significantly more resources to spend on litigation.

 

We could have potential indemnification liabilities to licensees relating to the operation of plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology or intellectual property disputes.

Our indemnification obligations could result in substantial expenses and liabilities to us if intellectual property rights claims were to be made against us or our licensees, or if plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology were to fail to operate as designed. Generally our license agreements require us to indemnify the licensee, subject to a cap of 50 percent of the license fees we receive, against specified losses relating to, among other things:

·         use of patent rights and technical information relating to the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology;

·         acts or omissions by us in connection with our preparation of Process design packages for plants; and

·         performance guarantees that we may provide.

 

Industry rejection of our technology would make the construction of plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology more difficult or impossible and would adversely affect our ability to receive future license fees, product revenue or other economic value.

Demand and industry acceptance for our GTL, CTL, BTL or Bio-Synfining™ Technology are subject to uncertainty. Failure by the industry to accept our technology would make construction of our plants more difficult or impossible, adversely affecting our ability to receive future license fees, product revenue, or other economic value. If any commercial plant based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology were to fail to achieve success, other industry participants’ perception of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or our Bio-Synfining™ Technology could be adversely affected.

Risks Relating to Products of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology

The U.S. renewable fuels industry is highly dependent on a mix of federal and state legislation and regulation and any changes in legislation or regulation could harm our business and financial condition.

Federal tax incentives make the cost of renewable diesel production significantly more competitive with the price of diesel. Currently, under the Energy Independence Act and the Energy Policy Act of 2005, or EPAct, producers of diesel/renewable diesel blends can claim up to a $1.00 tax credit per gallon. This credit is currently scheduled to terminate on December 31, 2009, and there can be no assurance that it will be renewed on similar terms, if at all. Additionally, producers of naphtha and liquid petroleum gases can claim a separate $0.50 per gallon tax credit. There can be no assurance of this credit’s continued existence, and its elimination would be harmful to our business and financial condition. Finally, these credits and other federal and state programs that benefit renewable diesel generally are subject to U.S. government obligations under international trade agreements, including those under the World Trade Organization Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures, which might in the future be the subject of challenges. The elimination or significant reduction in the renewable diesel tax credit or other programs could harm our results of operations and financial condition.

The Energy Independence Act and EPAct established minimum nationwide levels of renewable fuels, which include biodiesel, ethanol and any liquid fuel produced from biomass or biogas, to be blended into the fuel supply. By the year 2022, these standards require that the national volume of renewable fuels to be blended into the fuel supply equal or exceed 36 billion gallons. While these renewable fuel standards should stimulate demand for renewable fuels generally, there can be no assurance of specific demand for renewable diesel. Additionally, the U.S. Department of Energy, in consultation with the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of Energy, may waive the renewable fuels mandate with respect to one or more states if the Administrator of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, or EPA, determines that implementing the requirements would severely harm the economy or the environment of a state, a region or the U.S., or that there is inadequate supply to meet the requirement. Any waiver of the renewable fuel standards could adversely impact the demand for renewable diesel and may have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations.

Sufficient markets for the synthetic products of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology or products that utilize these synthetic products, including fuel cells, may never develop or may take longer to develop than we anticipate.

Sufficient markets may never develop for the synthetic products of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology, or may develop more slowly than we anticipate. The development of sufficient markets for the synthetic products of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes  or Bio-Synfining™ Technology may be affected by many factors, some of which are out of our control, including:

·         cost competitiveness of the synthetic products of the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes  or Bio-Synfining™ Technology;

·         consumer reluctance to try a new product;

·         environmental, safety and regulatory requirements; and

·         emergence of more competitive products.

 

 

In addition, a new market may fail to develop for products that utilize our synthetic products. For example, the establishment of a market for the use of these products as fuel for fuel cells is uncertain, in part because fuel cells represent an emerging market and we do not know if distributors will want to sell them or if end-users will want to use them.

If sufficient markets fail to develop or develop more slowly than we anticipate, we may be unable to recover the losses we will have incurred in the development of our technology and may never achieve profitability.

Risks Relating to Our Business

We will need to obtain funds from additional financings or other sources for our business activities. If we do not receive these funds, we would need to reduce, delay or eliminate some of our expenditures.

We have sustained recurring losses and negative cash flows from operations. Over the periods presented in the accompanying financial statements, our activities have been funded through a combination of equity and convertible debt financings and the sale of certain assets. As of December 31, 2007, we had approximately $18.4 million of cash and cash equivalents available to fund operations. We review cash flow forecasts and budgets periodically. We believe that we currently have sufficient cash and financing capabilities to meet our funding requirements until the end of 2009. However we will need to obtain additional funding for capital investment related to construction of plants utilizing the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology. In addition, we have experienced, and continue to experience, negative operating margins and negative cash flows from operations. 

We expect that we will need to raise substantial additional capital to accomplish our business plan over the next several years. In addition, we may wish to selectively pursue equity partnerships in certain gas or coal monetization projects in order to achieve operating efficiencies. We expect to seek to obtain additional funding through debt or equity financing in the capital markets, joint ventures, license agreements and other strategic alliances, as well as various other financing arrangements. If we obtain additional funds by issuing equity securities, dilution to stockholders may occur. In addition, preferred stock could be issued in the future without stockholder approval, and the terms of our preferred stock could include dividend, liquidation, conversion, voting and other rights that are more favorable than the rights of the holders of our common stock. There can be no assurance as to the availability or terms upon which such financing and capital might be available.

Our agreement with Tyson concerning Dynamic allows the participants to elect not to invest in a plant or to cease making capital contributions in the construction of a plant under certain circumstances. Should a participant in a project elect not to invest or to cease investing in the construction of the plant the other participants in the project will need to raise additional capital from third parties or to take on additional interest in the project and fund the additional capital internally. There can be no assurances that we would be able to raise the additional capital from third parties on terms acceptable to us or to fund the additional capital requirements internally.

 

If adequate funds are not available, we may be required to reduce, delay or eliminate expenditures for our plant development and other activities, or seek to enter into a business combination transaction with or sell assets to another company. We could also be forced to license to third parties the rights to commercialize additional products or technologies that we would otherwise seek to develop ourselves. The transactions outlined above may not be available to us when needed or on terms acceptable or favorable to us.

 

We need to remain listed on the NASDAQ stock market to be able to access adequate funding from time to time.  We face de-listing issues that would impair the liquidity of our stock and our availability to access the capital markets.  

 

On January 25, 2008 we received from The NASDAQ Stock Mark et a letter indicating that we were not in compliance with the market value minimum requirement for its common stock as set forth in Mark etplace Rule 4450(b)(1)(A). We were provided 30 calendar days, or until February 25, 2008, to regain compliance. We were unable to meet this requirement and have requested a hearing to appeal the delisting determination to a Listing Qualifications Panel. Pending this decision, we may apply to transfer our common stock to the NASDAQ Capital Mark et if it satisfies the requirements for continued listing.  We also received a NASDAQ Staff Deficiency Letter on February 1, 2008, indicating our common stock had closed below the minimum $1.00 per share requirement for continued inclusion under Mark etplace Rule 4450(a)(5). We are provided 180 calendar days, or until July 30, 2008, to regain compliance.  During this 180-day period, our shares will continue to trade on The NASDAQ Stock Mark et assuming our stock is not de-listed for failure to comply with the market value minimum requirement described above. The NASDAQ Stock Mark et has indicated that if at any time before July 30, 2008, the bid price of our common stock closes at $1.00 per share or more for a minimum of 10 consecutive business days, the Staff will determine if we have achieved compliance with the rule.  We can make no assurance that we will be able to remain listed on the NASDAQ Stock Mark et.

 

Construction of plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology will be subject to risks of delay and cost overruns.

The construction of plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology will be subject to the risks of delay or cost overruns resulting from numerous factors, including the following:

·         shortages of equipment, materials or skilled labor;

·         unscheduled delays in the delivery of ordered materials and equipment;

·         engineering problems, including those relating to the commissioning of newly designed equipment;

·         work stoppages;

·         weather interference;

·         unanticipated cost increases; and

·         difficulty in obtaining necessary permits or approvals.

 

We have a capital commitment to our joint venture, Dynamic, that requires us to fund our portion of the capital obligation for the plant.  This amount is estimated to be $75 million.  

We together with our partner, Tyson, must demonstrate in 2008 that we each have the financial resources to complete the first plant, which includes the capital budget for construction and initial operations, estimated to equal $150,000,000 in total.  If either party elects not to proceed with the construction of the first plant, then their interest reverts to the other party, who is then free to build the plant. If a member fails to make a capital contribution, it is in default, and its interest is diluted by $1.50 per $1.00 not contributed. The other member(s) can make a loan to the defaulting member at a rate of LIBOR +10% and there is a 40 day cure period. The defaulting member can make a full or partial loan repayment and a pro rata portion of lost interest will be restored. If the loan is not repaid, it will be converted into ownership interest for the member making the loan, diluting the defaulting member at the same rate of $1.00 per $1.00 of the loan.  We can not make assurances that will be able to secure financial resources in the time frame allowed by our agreement with Tyson. 

We have incurred losses and anticipate continued losses.

As of December 31, 2007, we had an accumulated deficit of $339.5 million. Although we generated net income for 2007, we have not yet achieved profitability from continuing operations and we expect to continue incurring net losses until we recognize sufficient revenues from licensing activities, plants utilizing the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™Technology or other sources. Because we do not have an operating history upon which an evaluation of our prospects can be based, our prospects must be considered in light of the risks, expenses and difficulties frequently encountered by small companies seeking to develop new and rapidly evolving technologies. To address these risks we must, among other things, continue to attract investment capital, respond to competitive factors, continue to attract, retain and motivate qualified personnel and commercialize and continue to upgrade the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes and Bio-Synfining™ technologies. We may not be successful in addressing these risks, and we may not achieve or sustain profitability.

Our anticipated expense levels are based in part on our expectations as to future operating activities and not on historical financial data. We plan to continue funding project development activities. Capital expenditures will depend on progress we make in developing various projects on which we are currently working. Increased revenues or cash flows may not result from these expenses.

If prices for crude oil, natural gas, coal, vegetable oils and fats and other commodities are unfavorable, plants based on the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology may not be economical.

Because the synthetic crude oil, liquid fuels and specialty products that plants utilizing the Syntroleum® and Synfining® Processes or Bio-Synfining™ Technology are expected to produce will compete in markets with oil and refined petroleum products, and because natural gas, coal, biomass, fats or vegetable oils will be used as the feedstock for these plants, an increase in feedstock prices relative to prices for oil or refined products, or a decrease in prices for oil or refined products relative to feedstock prices, could adversely affect the operating results of these plants.  Higher than anticipated costs for the catalysts and other materials used in these plants could also adversely affect operating results. Prices for oil, natural gas, coal, biomass, fats, greases, vegetable oils and refined products are subject to wide fluctuation in response to relatively minor changes in the supply and demand, market uncertainty and a variety of additional factors that are beyond our control. Factors that could cause changes in the prices and availability of oil, natural gas, coal, biomass, fats, vegetable oils and refined products include:

·         level of consumer product demand;

·         weather conditions;

·         domestic and foreign government regulation;